Although Davichi and T-ara collaborated prior to this single release, We Were in Love is the first collaboration single that only featured these two groups. Only Soyeon, Jiyeon, Hyomin and Hwayoung participated in this release as “T-ara”.
Released: December 23, 2011
1. We Were in Love (우리 사랑했잖아)
We Were in Love is a dramatic pop ballad that is more up Davichi’s alley than T-ara’s. It opens with a more “oldschool” take on things before coming right in with the chorus. The subtle beat, piano and violin really help to create a haunting quality. All the girls sound great here, especially the vocalists. While I do like the melody of the chorus because it is memorable, I feel like it could be taken to an even higher level and I’m not sure if that’s just the music because the vocals are on point, especially at the end. It’s still a nice ballad though and I like how the rapping is wrapped into the song.
Overall: This is a pretty solid collaboration between the two groups and shows the strengths of both groups. I don’t quite get the inclusion of Jiyeon as while her voice fits the calmer parts of the verse, she only has one short part. My only problem though is that I wish the music was tweak a bit because it remains the same level throughout.